Trump Directive Zeroes In On Utah Monuments

Apr 25, 2017

The new White House administration is officially stepping into the controversy over Bears Ears today. President Donald Trump is ordering a review of Utah’s newest national monument and possibly dozens more, including Grand Staircase Escalante.

U.S. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke said he’ll report his findings about the large monuments created in the past two decades, beginning with Bears Ears. He said several times he hasn't made up his mind already. He'll focus on the law and the people affected.

“The policy,” Zinke told reporters Tuesday, “is consistent with President Trump’s promise to give Americans a voice and make sure their voices are heard.”

Utah political leaders have vowed to get the Bears Ears monument scrapped ever since former President Barack Obama created it in December. They call it a “federal land grab” although its 1.3 million acres roughly follows the same footprint as conservation areas that Utahns in Congress have proposed for land already controlled by the federal government. Republican Sen. Orrin Hatch welcomed the new administration’s approach in a floor speech.

“In President Trump we have a leader who’s committed to defending the Western way of life,” the Utah senator said. “I am deeply grateful for his willingness to work with us to undo the harm caused.”

But there’s opposition, too.

One environmental group called the review an attack on federal public lands. And a member of the Native American coalition who pushed for Bears Ears is asking why the only monument requested by tribes is now being questioned.

“In one breath, the United States embraces, and even the state of Utah embraces,”said Shaun Chapoose leads the Ute tribe. “But in the second breath it’s almost saying to me, ‘You don’t really matter’.”

Secretary Zinke said he’s coming to Utah to observe the issues firsthand.

Tags: